55 S Elmwood Ave, 11954
If you can't decide between the pool and the beach, the Montauk Beach House offers both... plus acupuncture, massage therapy and an all day outdoor bar serving the best Pimm's Cup this side of Long Island. Located in the center of town, you can walk to nearby South Edison to try authentic sustainably raised lobster and oysters straight from the Atlantic Ocean. Alternatively, dance the day away poolside with DJ sets by the likes of Talib Kweli and Brandon Fallis. Bring your friends and share a room, because MBH has spacious quarters with luxury bunk beds that take the humble sleepover party to a new level.